Sunday, April 12, 2009

(Deathly Hallows) Was Lily Potter's Patronus a doe?

(spoiler warning~)





Hello,


Anyone knows which parts in HP books 1~7 mentioned that Lily Potter%26#039;s Patronus was a doe?


How did harry know that Lily Potter%26#039;s Patronus was a doe?





I really have no idea of that.





(except the part which Harry said, %26quot;Snape%26#039;s Patronus was a doe, the same as my mother%26#039;s.%26quot;)





If Lily Potter%26#039;s Patronus was really a doe,


then was Harry a fawn, then? since his dad was a stag. (It reminds me of a Disney movie)





Anyone knows what is the meaning of deer in magical world?





Thanks a lot.

(Deathly Hallows) Was Lily Potter%26#039;s Patronus a doe?
~I think he guessed it. If he had known he would have thought his mother had guided him to the sword rather than wondered throughout the entire book who it could have been.
Reply:harry%26#039;s patronous was a stag witch is a real animal but i havent read the final book yet so i dont kno i just finished book 6 today so im buying the new one tomorrow
Reply:he knew that because dumbledore told him.








No, harry%26#039;s was a stag like his dad%26#039;s.








IDK
Reply:harry%26#039;s was a stag.





and yes his mother%26#039;s was a doe.
Reply:yes lily%26#039;s is a doe...and harry%26#039;s is a stag as well. i don%26#039;t know what a deer is in magical world and i don%26#039;t know how harry knew his mother%26#039;s patronus was a doe. but harry%26#039;s is definetly a stag and lily%26#039;s a doe.
Reply:PROJECT HEROSTRATUS





*SNAPE IS ON DUMBLEDORE%26#039;S SIDE, HE GETS KILLED BY NAGINI


*BELLATRIX KILLS DOBBY


*FRED DIES


*TONKS DIES, LUPIN DIES


*CRABBE DIES, HEDWIG DIES


*MAD EYE MOODY GETS AVADA KEDAVRA%26#039;D


*COLIN CREEVEY DIES


*LUNA%26#039;S FATHER BETRAYS HARRY TO THE DEATH EATERS


*PETTIGREW GETS CHOKED LIKE BART BY HIS OWN SILVER HAND


*MRS WEASLEY KILLS BELLATRIX





*THE GREY LADY IS THE DAUGHTER OF RAVENCLAW


*THE ROOM OF REQUIREMENT HAS A VANISHING CABINET THAT CONTAINS A HORCRUX


*UMBRIDGE HAS SLYTHERIN%26#039;S LOCKET


*HUFFLEPUFF%26#039;S CUP IS IN BELLATRIX LESTRANGE%26#039;S VAULT


*NEVILLE IS THE NEW HERBOLOGY PROFESSOR


*HARRY POTTER’S INVISIBILITY CLOAK IS ONE OF THE DEATHLY HALLOWS


*HARRY POTTER IS A HORCRUX


says


Yes it was a doe.
Reply:I don%26#039;t know. I don%26#039;t think it was ever actually said what her patronus was. Harry just assumes it was because his dad was a stag animagus, but that really doesn%26#039;t mean anything. Either it%26#039;s a mistake or we were told somewhere but it got cut out along the way.
Reply:Just thought i%26#039;d point out to %26quot;Unique%26quot; that Hermione%26#039;s patronums isn%26#039;t a beaver. It%26#039;s an Otter. It has nothing to do with facial features, such as teeth.
Reply:POSSIBLE SPOILER





I don%26#039;t believe it has a meaning your patronus takes form from your personallity or just fom you...Ron%26#039;s patronus is a weasle cause his last name......Hermione%26#039;s patronus is a I like a beaver or a badger..beacise of her teeth.....get it.... And if I%26#039;m not mistaken that is the only mentioning of Lily patronus being a doe I don%26#039;t think it came up in any of the other books..............





PS: Your question is Kinda a spoiler.
Reply:It wasn%26#039;t mentioned that Lily%26#039;s Patronus was a doe, but it was more Albus%26#039;s reaction to Snape%26#039;s Patronus that hints at the similarity between Lily%26#039;s and Snape%26#039;s Patronuses. Remember that in %26quot;Half-Blood Prince%26quot; Tonks%26#039;s Patronus changed when Remus refused to be with her. JKR said in a recent web chat that a person%26#039;s Patronus %26quot;often mutates to take the image of the love of one’s life (because they so often become the ‘happy thought’ that generates a Patronus)%26quot;.





Harry%26#039;s Patronus is, and has always been a stag, his father%26#039;s Animagus form, because, as mentioned in %26quot;Prisoner of Azkaban%26quot;, his father lives in him.
Reply:Lily%26#039;s patronus was never mentioned in books 1-6.





Harry finds out what her Patronus was by watching Snape%26#039;s memories in the Pensieve. Snape gave the memories to Harry as he (Snape) died.





Lily%26#039;s patronus has nothing to do with Harry. The form of the Patronus seems to be an expression of a person%26#039;s best quality.





There is no set meaning of deer mentioned in the Harry Potter magical world.
Reply:Lily%26#039;s was a doe. Snape%26#039;s, because of his love for Lily, was also a doe. Harry%26#039;s took the form his father, and animagus, transformed into. A stag.
Reply:It is not mentioned. I think Harry knows it from the pensieve... Because if it was mentioned before the end of book 7, Harry woudl obviously know that it%26#039;s his mother%26#039;s patronus and he would get confused. They are also trying to find out who%26#039;s patronus it is. So it just wouldn%26#039;t make sense if Harry knew. I think it was from the pensieve
Reply:UM WELL REMENBER THAT SOME GREAT WIZARDS CAN CHANGE THERE PATRONUS AND MAYBE SNAPE LOVED LILY VERY,VERY MUCH THAT HE CHANGED HIS PATRONUS LIKE HERS. THATS WHAT I THINK?



beauty

No comments:

Post a Comment